Stone-Throwing Chimp Back In the News With Better Plan 235
sciencehabit writes "Three years ago, a stone-throwing chimpanzee named Santino jolted the research community by providing some of the strongest evidence yet that non-humans could plan ahead. Santino, a resident of the Furuvik Zoo in Gävle, Sweden, calmly gathered stones in the mornings and put them into neat piles, apparently saving them to hurl at visitors when the zoo opened as part of angry and aggressive 'dominance displays.' But some researchers were skeptical that Santino really was planning for a future emotional outburst. Now Santino is back in the scientific literature, the subject of new claims that he has begun to conceal the stones so he can get a closer aim at his targets—further evidence that he is thinking ahead like humans do."
evidence that he is thinking ahead like humans... (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:evidence that he is thinking ahead like humans. (Score:5, Funny)
Well yeah, if humans threw stones at people we'd put them in a cage too called "jail"
Re:evidence that he is thinking ahead like humans. (Score:5, Insightful)
Well yeah, if humans threw stones at people we'd put them in a cage too called "jail"
Usually the way that works is you throw the stones first and then get put in a cage. Not the other way around.
Re:evidence that he is thinking ahead like humans. (Score:5, Interesting)
Yeah, we should send the little guy back to the Congo so the locals can eat him [janegoodall.ca].
Re:evidence that he is thinking ahead like humans. (Score:5, Funny)
Or start leaving guns around in his enclosure until he learns how to defend himself and starts eating the locals
Re:evidence that he is thinking ahead like humans. (Score:5, Funny)
Re:evidence that he is thinking ahead like humans. (Score:4, Funny)
Re:evidence that he is thinking ahead like humans. (Score:4, Funny)
Quick! Start throwing stones!
Casting the first stone (Score:5, Funny)
You should be punished for that.
Quick! Start throwing stones!
First let's find one of us who hasn't done anything wrong. Then we'll let him throw the first stone.
Re:evidence that he is thinking ahead like humans. (Score:5, Funny)
I support the right to arm bears.
Re:evidence that he is thinking ahead like humans. (Score:5, Funny)
Quite right, proper nouns especially are exempt. Could you Xerox your thesis on the subject for me, or should I Google it?
All living languages continuously evolve through such abuse, and no doubt the early adopters always look like idiots. No sense getting upset about it.
Re: (Score:2)
That was before we had precogs. Welcome to the future, caveman.
Re: (Score:3, Interesting)
And we also seem to realize that taking kids on field trips to see humans in jail wouldn't be prudent either.
Not the case - I was on a traveling football team in my younger years (early teen). We had drug and theft issues running through the community and team. We were actually brought to see the humans in jail. I decided at that moment that it was never going to be the place for me. Maybe we should take MORE of our kids to see humans in jail.
Re: (Score:3)
And we also seem to realize that taking kids on field trips to see humans in jail wouldn't be prudent either.
Not the case - I was on a traveling football team in my younger years (early teen). We had drug and theft issues running through the community and team. We were actually brought to see the humans in jail. I decided at that moment that it was never going to be the place for me. Maybe we should take MORE of our kids to see humans in jail.
A friend of mine in law enforcement explained to me that those "scared straight" programs are mostly worthless. The kids come in, take a look, and say "Oh that isn't going to be me, I am way smarter than those fools."
he's throwing WHAT?! oh, never mind... (Score:3)
Re:evidence that he is thinking ahead like humans. (Score:5, Funny)
Re: (Score:3, Funny)
So the detention without a trial that was approved in the US is just an extension of what was already done to the monkeys? It's nice to know the US is working towards interspecies equality!
Re: (Score:3)
Re: (Score:2)
It is even better to know there is no zoos in the US... freedom for the monkeys! At least for them.
Re:evidence that he is thinking ahead like humans. (Score:5, Funny)
Except we call his relative's cages "cubes."
Now, excuse me, I need to go have my banana for lunch.
Re: (Score:3)
You wait until lunch? I have a banana break at 10:30 each morning.
Re: (Score:2)
You wait until lunch? I have a banana break at 10:30 each morning.
You get breaks?
Re:evidence that he is thinking ahead like humans. (Score:5, Funny)
Re:evidence that he is thinking ahead like humans. (Score:5, Funny)
MY banana break is at 11:45, and we start throwing feces around 3:12 pm. Unless the hot receptionist is here, then we all run around with our chests puffed up...
BRB, I need to jump on daves desk and scream at him.
Just another day in Corporate america.
Re: (Score:2)
Eating each others lice on break is relaxing though...
Re: (Score:2)
Just like in CareerBuilder commercials/advertisements (ads.)/spots on television/TV. ;)
Re: (Score:2)
In lieu of (+6, Sad-But-True), please accept this cartoon, which hangs on my cage wall: I'm the next contestant on the hot new game show: Who's the dumb ape? [thebaba.com]
Re: (Score:2)
Since they're that smart, they'd have escaped already if they wanted it. They're just waiting and giving us a false sense of security until they make their move for global revolution.
Re:evidence that he is thinking ahead like humans. (Score:4, Funny)
they're in sweden. they might have figured out it's not worth escaping to the wild.
the dude still needs a way to show off aggressive dominance to get chicks though, regardless of imprisonment.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Considering he seems to be acting like a cranky old man, and considering where we stick our cranky elderly relatives? Sounds like he is a bit better ahead.
Re: (Score:3)
Feel free to go give one a hug, they rip faces off.
They need to be in a cage...otherwise the next step is the statue of liberty buried up to her neck on a beach!
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
we could treat him like a human and see how he does. http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,494067,00.html [foxnews.com]
Or we could leave wild animals in, I don't know, the wild perhaps. I don't have a problem with using animals for justified medical/behavioral experiments. Or herd animals for food for that matter. But primates do not make good pets and are, for the most part, too intelligent to stick in cages for their entire life simply to entertain humans.
WhT is the time scale of "plan"? (Score:2)
Re: (Score:3)
My dog is the type of moron who will walk into walls because he's distracted, but he's executed surprisingly complex plots when it comes to stealing rawhide from the other dog. He even has a Plan B called "whine until Daddy gets annoyed and fills the Kong with cheese whiz which is even better!"
Re: (Score:3)
*snip* Maybe this has to do with the time scale - she would usually make 5 minute plans, rather than 2 hours or whatever the monkey's time scale is.
I don't wish to sound petty, but chimpanzees are apes. I'm sure you know that but if a monkey was seen planning like this then it would be much bigger news. As you say, it's probably a question of timescales; our dog may have been bright but I can't recall her ever planning like this unless you count burying things in the garden.
Re: (Score:3)
I was just trying to avoid any donkey cart-related incidents.
Re:WhT is the time scale of "plan"? (Score:5, Interesting)
Dogs always know what time it is. If they could speak they would tell you: "It's now" - that is, they can't really plan ahead. They can plan for the moment, within the limits of their working (short -term) memory. And they can internalize lessons from long-term experience and modify their behavior, such as not stealing food off the table after getting punished several times for it. But they have no capacity to reason about what might happen in the more-than-immediate future and decide what to do based on that. For example, the dog that won't steal food in front of you, may very well steal it when you are out of sight, never realizing that you will know what took place and get mad at it, but acting very guilty when you return to the room because it will only then realize it is in trouble.
Elephants, on the other hand, based on my own anecdotal "evidence", anyway, appear to be able to plan ahead as well as the chimp in TFA. When I was involved in the gutting and remaking of the building housing elephants, giraffes, etc. at our local zoo, the architect pointed out to me the brown spots on the wall behind the visitor's gallery. It turns out that the poor, bored animal was throwing its' dung at the visitors. The interesting part, though, was that when the zookeepers realized this, and cleaned up the poop before the visitors arrived, the elephant started planning ahead and hiding their excrement on top of the barrier poles so it would be available to throw at the gawkers (the poles were more than 8 feet high and large enough to conceal the dung from the zookeepers). This apparently amused the elephant, as it was done to the squealing delight of all the visiting schoolchildren - those that weren't hit by the shit, anyway.
Bullwinkle never knew (Score:3, Interesting)
Re: (Score:2)
The difference being a survival instinct vs. plans for an emotional outburst.
Re: (Score:2)
I think that's more of a burying instinct; they don't actually remember where they bury them, but if there are enough buried all around they have a decent chance of finding one when the start looking.
Re: (Score:2)
I think the difference here is that squirrels do it on an instinctive level... and the vast majority of the nuts they store never get used and the few that are usually get re-discovered by accident. Squirrels don't show any evidence of storing nuts because they know it will be cold... just that's what instinct drives them to do. I'd bet that if you took a squirrel at birth and kept it somewhere that's always a stable, warm temperature then it would still store nuts even though it had no idea why it was doin
Re:Bullwinkle never knew (Score:5, Funny)
Would you claim it is just instinct that causes cats to lurk on stairs, and they're not planning for when a person walks by?
Re: (Score:2)
Would you claim it is just instinct that causes cats to lurk on stairs, and they're not planning for when a person walks by?
Pak chooie meow?
Re:Bullwinkle never knew (Score:5, Funny)
No. Cats are obviously evil genius masterminds who have plans stretching from the dawn of time until the re-awakening of the Great Old Ones. No instinct - just pure, unadulterated malevolence.
Re:Bullwinkle never knew (Score:5, Funny)
"This is a cat. He doesn't hate you because you're black, brown or yellow, or because you're a homosexual, or a Republican, or a Democrat. He hates you because he's a cat."
Re: (Score:2)
They hear you coming and want to play. That's not planning.
Re:Bullwinkle never knew (Score:5, Insightful)
learning to lie (Score:5, Insightful)
He isn't just planning ahead, and then coming up with a new plan. He's being deceptive.
Re: (Score:3)
And what surer sign of intelligence do we have?
Re:learning to lie (Score:5, Funny)
He isn't just planning ahead, and then coming up with a new plan. He's being deceptive.
And what surer sign of intelligence do we have?
Having the qualities necessary to be an attorney, politician, or investment banker does not constitute intelligence.
Stone-Throwing Chimpanzee Lawyer (Score:5, Insightful)
Your honor, I'm a chimpanzee. Your scientists saw me stacking stones and then hiding them and so they sent me to law school. Your world frightens and confuses me! When someone sends me a text message on my iPhone I wonder, "are there tiny people inside typing it?" I don't know. But I do know this: when someone like my client slips and falls on the sidewalk in front of a public library, he is entitled to two million dollars in compensatory damages and two million in punitive damages. Thank you.
Re: (Score:2)
If you're so smart, why aren't you rich?
The wise don't always have food, and the intelligent aren't always rich.
Re: (Score:3)
Comparing to some of the baggers at the local supermarket, I'd question the intelligence classification of humans (not all baggers are morons).
Re: (Score:3)
If he reports a fault in the AE35 unit, don't go out to fix it.
Re: (Score:2)
So what? Any animal that plays dead is being deceptive. Any that uses camouflage or mimicry is being deceptive. Cats use deception to fool their prey into believing they aren't paying attention. Deception isn't in short supply in the animal kingdom.
Re: (Score:2)
There's a difference between instinct and learning.
Well? Cats learn (Score:2)
My cat responds with an innocent expression if I ask if it ate the salmon I was preparing. My kitten looks proud stating "Yes I eated it, it was delicious, got some more". Same as kids, kids don't know how to lie when they are young. Then they learn it badly (lying when the evidence is right there) and then they learn deception.
A lot of this research is problematic. A fish eagle is known to be able to do all it needs to do in a day in few minutes, it is such an effective hunter. So... is it a dumb or smart
Re: (Score:2)
There is a difference between deception at a species level (e.g. mimicry, stalking behavior), and the deception at an individual level that is going on here.
nah, just casting the first stone (Score:3)
No, not deceptive.
He's just showing off his knowledge and understanding of our human religious scriptures, as well as showing that he himself is without sin.
Sheesh. You psychologist-type people will just read ANYthing into some situations. ;-)
Re: (Score:2)
So when does he start at Yahoo?
Yay for science! (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:Yay for science! (Score:5, Informative)
Re: (Score:2)
I saw that one time on some special. There was a small group of chimps, 4 I think, who climbed up trees and surrounded a monkey. The monkey kept jumping from tree limb to tree limb trying to escape but in the end, the chimps caught him. The next thing they did was beat the bugger against the tree until it was dead and then ate him.
So, we have planning (I want to eat that monkey), group coordination (you go there, I'll
Re: (Score:2)
How is that all that different than a pack of wolves finding, stalking and killing prey?
I agree that Apes are intelligent, more so than canines, but this is a poor example.
Re: (Score:2)
Slaughter and EAT them. Chimps are cannibals if the opportunity presents itself. They are also known to have troop members that can only be described as very malicious to the point that human observers report them as being evil. Google "Frodo the Chimpanzee".
Re: (Score:2)
After reading the despicable evils and atrocities that primates, especially Chimpanzees, are capable of in this book by Carl Sagan and his wife:
http://www.amazon.com/Shadows-Forgotten-Ancestors-Carl-Sagan/dp/0345384725 [amazon.com]
I am convinced that evil is a trait we share with all primates, and that it somehow evolved at the primate level, and is not unique to humans. And it's just not chimps: gorillas and baboons as well.
I am getting sick just recalling some of the stuff in that book.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
I think you're confusing "weakened restatement of an opposing position" with "noting the absurd (also being self-contradictory is just a bonus here) conclusions required by the opposing position".
The first is a Straw Man. The second is a Reductio Ad Absurdum. The first is a fallacy, the second is a refutation.
Re: (Score:2)
Meh (Score:5, Interesting)
I would go and see this chimp if they would let me throw the stones back at him. Hell, I'd even pay good money.
Re: (Score:3)
You wouldn't want that. I promise you, he's a lot better at it than you are.
Re:Meh (Score:5, Funny)
From inside or outside the cage, tough guy?
Primate Dominance Displays (Score:2)
Santino, a resident of the Furuvik Zoo in Gävle, Sweden, calmly gathered stones in the mornings and put them into neat piles, apparently saving them to hurl at visitors when the zoo opened as part of angry and aggressive 'dominance displays.'
As a stone-thrower, he's already advanced further politically than we have, seeing as how we are still at the poo-throwing dominance display stage.
Me too. (Score:5, Funny)
I tried this at work but the custodial staff kept finding my little piles of rocks and removing them from my office. Sometimes it doesn't pay to plan ahead.
Re: (Score:2)
Why do you think he learned to hide them?
Perhaps you could ape him.
Re: (Score:2)
Clearly, you need bigger rocks.
what's next? (Score:3)
For all his advanced planning (Score:5, Interesting)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
It is interesting to note that the concepts behind Eugenigs - racism and nativism - are generally advocated by conservatives today. You might want to be careful how and where you throw those stones.
Andy Warhol (Score:2)
"In the future, everyone will be world-famous for 15 minutes, except stone-throwing chimps, that will be for 30."
Wrong name (Score:2)
No, Santino aka Sonny [wikipedia.org] was the hot headed one as evinced by his death at the tollbooth. This ape, his methodical planning sounds much more like a Michael [wikipedia.org] to me. I suspect the research community was tipped off by an ape named Fredo, the stupid git.
No kidding Sherlock (Score:4, Interesting)
My family was driving through Florida in the 60s and we stopped at some wretched “jungle zoo” by the side of the road. I ran ahead of the rest looking at the really sad caged animals and saw the chimp cage. It had ragged poly sheets hanging in front with big holes and tears in them with a chimp sitting quietly. As soon as I got close enough, the chimp sprayed me with a most foul mouthful of something bad and jumped down to a bucketful of nasty and sucked up another huge mouthful.
I wasn’t the brightest bulb on the tree but even I knew to run like hell. This happened in full view of my family who promptly collapsed in hysterical laughter. The chimp knew exactly what it was doing and planned accordingly.
Oh. (Score:2)
So this is what happens when stone-throwing chimps are kept away from /b/ !
Who let the chimp touch the Monolith? (Score:2)
Next thing you know, he'll be swinging bones at visitors,,,
Who's advanced? (Score:2)
So we have a chimp that is showing remarkable signs of intelligence, and the best activity we can come up with for him is to stick in him a cage and let the tourists ogle him?
It's cute how we like to pretend we're "advanced".
Bias (Score:2)
One of the issues I see in this whole debate is the bias, intentional or unintentional, of the observer. It seems that some observers have the idea that apes have the ability to plan ahead. It is quite possible that observations are being interpreted to fit the hypothesis when there may be other explanations. It could just be an extension of learning hunting skills. Would a large cat that conceals himself near a game trail be considered to be planning ahead like a human? All hunters do similar things but ar
Re: (Score:2)
Instinct vs. learned behavior.
Hell, even my dog plans ahead. (Score:5, Interesting)
I live with two pit-bull terriers (both rescued strays), and unfortunately I must keep them in separate rooms because of a traumatic event where during play the one's jaw got caught under the other's collar -- They remember this episode, but confuse it with each hurting the other; Ever since they fight if left together unsupervised for a length of time.
The one dog, TC (named after the street T.C. Jester where she was found), likes being in the larger part of the house, and would rather not be in the den. So, when I say that "It's time to switch the dogs", and try to put her in the Den, she runs to the back door instead, as if she needs to relieve herself. She knows that the dog in the house usually ends up in the den when the outside dog is let back inside -- to keep them separated.
If while coming back inside she realises that I'll be putting the other dog outside -- making her more likely to be the dog in the den, then she's resistant to coming back inside... She not only thinks ahead, she's worked out several plans to achieve her goal. If TC knows its her turn to have run of the house, then none of this is an issue, she goes in and out without a care, knowing that it's the other dog that'll be relegated to the den -- Even if she sees the other dog going out when she comes in, she's not reluctant to come inside because she's not planning on being put in the den.
Furthermore, I'm beginning to run out of ways to say "Walk" and "Car" -- The dogs love riding in the car, and have learned that "C.A.R." means car, "Truck" and "T.R.U.C.K" is also out, can't say or spell "go" without them getting excited to leave -- Currently I've taken to saying, "Vamonos en el Auto" which is me butchering Spanish (never formally studied it, but I've run out of French and English words), because they've also learned "coche"; However, TC has started to pick up on this too -- You can see her perk up and look between the parties as if she's sussing out whether or not we'll soon be leaving. Names of vacation places, such as "Kerville" must be avoided at all cost -- I sometimes attend the Kerville Folk Festival for a week or so and have the neighbour care for one dog at the house while the other is in a kennel (to ensure separation), TC gets distressed when Kerville is mentioned -- She picks it up even in the middle of rapid speech with other parties. TC normally loves to get the leash so we can go for a walk, but Mention Kerville at all and she runs away from the leash for several days. She's planning not to be the dog in the kennel.
Humans are so damn chauvinistic. There's no such thing as "sentience" -- That's some made up Bullshit right there. There is only varying degrees of awareness and intellect depending on the complexity of the neural network. Bigger network? Smarter. That's all there is to it.
When (not if) machine learning neural networks surpass the complexity of the human mind by leaps and bounds: I sure hope they're understanding enough of our primitive nature, and don't treat us lesser minded humans as we treat the apes and other creatures with proportionally less neurons. Note that I didn't say I own the dogs...
Re: (Score:2)
It is possible to teach the dogs not to fight rather than relegating them to eternal separation. You should look into it, if you care about them you spend the time and money it takes to teach them to not be afraid of each other.
My lab was attacked, for as best I can guess not being submissive enough to another dog, and has been suspicious of other dogs to the point of growling and getting ready to fight when they are around. I don't tolerate that behavior and I get very loud and simulate major angry when sh
Is this really special? (Score:3)
Sometimes I wonder why it takes researchers so long to discover attributes in animals that any pet owner has observed countless times.
Here's one incident that comes to mind:
A couple of years ago my father picked up my cat, as he's done many a time. But this time he took him over to another cat who, for whatever reason, he hated with passion. He patiently let my father hold him and return him to the other room. The instant my father released him the cat turned and bit him with all his strength.
Instead of freaking out while in a compromised position he patiently waited to exact his revenge when he was reasonably safe. That sounds fairly good control of emotion and planning to me. It's not collecting rocks, but I think it's compelling nonetheless.
How about pets training owners into performing desired actions?
job one - get smarty chimp's DNA recorded (Score:2)
That could be some very interesting data. Hail Caesar!
I misunderstood the summary title (Score:3)
Re: (Score:3)
Next week Scientist discover that animals hate fire because it's hot.
Animals don't hate fire because it's hot. They hate fire because it is hot AND filthy rich...
Duh, indeed (Score:3)
There's a difference between doing something by instinct, and developing a new behavior in response to personal experiences. Squirrels don't bury food because they remember getting hungry last winter; they just do it. Leopards certainly don't "plan their menu for tomorrow". A dog bringing toys to the front door is simply a learned behavior, repeating something they did by chance previously that resulted in a positive outcome. What appears to be happening here is the chimp devising a new behavior, not by
Re:Duh, indeed (Score:4, Interesting)
What appears to be happening here is the chimp devising a new behavior, not by chance, but by anticipating the future.
Your premise is flawed. By your definition, the Dog is the same as the Chimp -- The chimp found by chance leaving the stones out of the view of humans gave him better chance to throw them. He learned by chance that gathering the stones first allowed him to throw more at the people. Just like you learned by chance that uttering "mama" or "dada" invoked positive responses.
I put it to you that all neural networks learn thus. Cognition is merely an ongoing wave of synaptic re-configuring. Internalising an episode of memory is no different than experiencing it, and any creature (such as a dog) that has an episodic memory can reflect upon the past events, devising an action in the moment. Planning ahead? Seriously? That's no different than trying something different in the moment -- The time scales are simply larger in the former. The more neurons and synapses the more complex the neural network.
For example: A dog must decide -- translate the internal desire into action. It begins with the desire for a treat, sensing this desire and the opportunity at hand they decide, then act. If the human isn't in the room to give the treat, they don't bring the treat to the door when they want a snack! Sense, Decide, Act! It's the basis of logic. If I bring this toy to the door the human will reward me. THAT'S PLANNING AHEAD. They don't just mindlessly crave a treat and arrive at the door toy in mouth. Somewhere in that dog's mind the must conclude, this action will lead to the satisfaction of my desire. It's actually a primitive form of communication you chauvinist.
The ape is thinking, it may not use words, but just because it has fewer neurons doesn't mean the animals do not reason or plan. THINK MAN!
Re: (Score:2)
Maybe he just needs more fiber in his diet?